Probe E# — E-Sharp AB
Probe is made by E# (E-Sharp AB) in Sweden. Want your own boards reviewed like this? Book a meeting

CUTE WR DP

OHWR0031 · revision R1

CUTE WR DP (OHWR0031 R1) is an open-hardware circuit board from the CERN Open Hardware Repository, designed in Altium Designer: a 8-layer board of 76.5 × 69 mm with 196 components and 208 nets, published under CERN-OHL-1.1.

review 88% walked · 11 findings: 5 major · 6 minor (16 items)

Open in the interactive viewerRead the full review

CUTE WR DP (OHWR0031 R1) circuit board, top view: copper, silkscreen and components
Top view, rendered by Probe from the design's own fabrication data.

Design review

Probe recorded 11 findings: 5 major · 6 minor (16 items) on this design. Each is shown here with its reasoning; the full review links every one to the pins, nets and datasheet pages it rests on.

  1. observationOBS-530majorOpen

    FMC 3P3VAUX (D32) is tied to the 3P3V contacts and feeds the whole board

    The FMC 3P3VAUX contact (D32) is tied straight to the four 3P3V contacts on one net, P3V3_AUX, so the whole board can run from a supply the standard limits to 20 mA, and can back-feed the carrier's 3P3V rail.

    Where it is

    J1 contact (ASP-134488-01)VITA 57.1 signalBoard net
    D323P3VAUXP3V3_AUX
    C39, D36, D38, D403P3VP3V3_AUX

    P3V3_AUX then feeds the board's main 3.3 V rail P3V3 through fuse F1 (0154003.DR); P3V3 has about 40 device power pins, including the FPGA and the TPS62130 U2 that makes the 1.5 V and 1.2 V rails.

    ``mermaid flowchart LR AUX[J1 D32 3P3VAUX] --> N[P3V3_AUX] V33[J1 C39/D36/D38/D40 3P3V] --> N N --> F1 --> P3V3[P3V3: FPGA, U2, SFP, ...] ``

    What the standard says

    ItemVITA 57.1Source
    3P3VAUX maximum current20 mATable 11, p.70
    3P3V maximum current3 ATable 11, p.70
    3P3VAUX presencemay be present when no other voltage isObservation 5.25, p.72
    Sharing3P3VAUX and 3P3V should not share common paths on the mezzanineObservation 5.26, p.72

    Why it matters

    A carrier may source 3P3VAUX from a standby supply (Rule 5.101 allows its 3.3 V AUX). With this module fitted and the carrier's 3P3V switched off, the standby supply sees the whole module as its load (well beyond 20 mA), and it also drives the carrier's own 3P3V net backwards through the four 3P3V contacts. On a carrier that ties both pins to one rail the two merge harmlessly, which is presumably the carrier this design was tested on.

    Suggested fix: take the board supply from the 3P3V contacts only, and use 3P3VAUX only for the IPMI EEPROM (or leave it unconnected).

  2. DecapViaFanoutmajorOpen

    C57 on 'P1V2': its rail pad reaches its via over 2.95 mm of track, adding about 0.94 nH to its loop, past Probe's 0.5 nH starting value; put the vias at the pads

    C57 on 'P1V2': its rail pad reaches its via over 2.95 mm of track, adding about 0.94 nH to its loop, past Probe's 0.5 nH starting value; put the vias at the pads. C57.2 (rail) runs 2.95 mm along its copper to its nearest via, 1.95 mm past the 1 mm beside the pad: 0.94 nH; C57.1 (ground) not measured: the pad sits in a pour of its net on its own layer, which has no track length to measure. Each run past the pad as one conductor of a pair 1.40 mm apart (the pad pitch), 0.2 l ln(D/R) nH with R 0.127 mm (the track's width is not read): 0.94 nH in all. Put the vias at the pads (or in them), one per pad at least, the rail's and the ground's close together; the capacitor's own inductance as mounted is 0.82 nH (pad 0.10 nH + no via of the first net within 1 mm of its pad: the study's 0.6 nH per mm of 0.36 mm depth, ASSUMED). 0.5 nH is Probe's starting value, about the whole mounted inductance of a well-mounted 0402.

    At C57

  3. DecapOrdermajorOpen

    DecapOrder: 3 findings (2 components, 1 pin)×3

    e.g. “IC2 supply pins 1, 4 on 'P3V3_CLEAN': the smallest capacitor C2 sits 4.6 mm away, behind C4 at 2.3 mm” · 3 different statements

    At IC2, OSC2.4, U1

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • IC2IC2 supply pins 1, 4 on 'P3V3_CLEAN': the smallest capacitor C2 sits 4.6 mm away, behind C4 at 2.3 mm

      IC2 supply pins 1, 4 on 'P3V3_CLEAN': the smallest capacitor C2 sits 4.6 mm away, behind C4 at 2.3 mm. IC2.1: the smallest value, C2 (10 nF), is 4.6 mm from the pin and C4 (100 nF) 2.3 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. IC2.4: the smallest value, C2 (10 nF), is 3.1 mm from the pin and C4 (100 nF) 0.8 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. Swap them, or bring the smallest value to the pin: it serves the fastest current and is the one the loop inductance defeats. Distances are pad centre to pin centre in the board plane. The 5 mm radius, the 10x value step and the 1 mm / 1.5x tie tolerance are Probe's starting values.

    • OSC2.4OSC2 supply pin 4 on 'OSC2VS': the smallest capacitor C10 sits 3.3 mm away, behind C8 at 1.7 mm

      OSC2 supply pin 4 on 'OSC2VS': the smallest capacitor C10 sits 3.3 mm away, behind C8 at 1.7 mm. OSC2.4: the smallest value, C10 (10 nF), is 3.3 mm from the pin and C8 (1 uF) 1.7 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. Swap them, or bring the smallest value to the pin: it serves the fastest current and is the one the loop inductance defeats. Distances are pad centre to pin centre in the board plane. The 5 mm radius, the 10x value step and the 1 mm / 1.5x tie tolerance are Probe's starting values.

    • U1U1 supply pins B17, D14, E17, G15, J17, P5, R2, U14, U4 on 'P3V3': the smallest capacitor C45 sits 4.1 mm away, behind C43 at 2.4 mm

      U1 supply pins B17, D14, E17, G15, J17, P5, R2, U14, U4 on 'P3V3': the smallest capacitor C45 sits 4.1 mm away, behind C43 at 2.4 mm. U1.B17: the smallest value, C45 (1 uF), is 4.1 mm from the pin and C43 (22 uF) 2.4 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. U1.D14: the smallest value, C52 (100 nF), is 3.9 mm from the pin and C49 (1 uF) 2.3 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. U1.E17: the smallest value, C54 (100 nF), is 4.8 mm from the pin and C43 (22 uF) 0.7 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. U1.G15: the smallest value, C54 (100 nF), is 2.5 mm from the pin and C45 (1 uF) 0.4 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. U1.J17: the smallest value, C54 (100 nF), is 3.2 mm from the pin and C33 (22 uF) 1.8 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. U1.P5: the smallest value, C61 (100 nF), is 3.6 mm from the pin and C48 (1 uF) 1.2 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. U1.R2: the smallest value, C59 (100 nF), is 4.4 mm from the pin and C48 (1 uF) 1.4 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. U1.U14: the smallest value, C60 (100 nF), is 3.6 mm from the pin and C46 (1 uF) 0.9 mm: the high-frequency part sits behind more inductance than the bulk part, which needs it least. And 1 more pin(s) the same way. Swap them, or bring the smallest value to the pin: it serves the fastest current and is the one the loop inductance defeats. Distances are pad centre to pin centre in the board plane. The 5 mm radius, the 10x value step and the 1 mm / 1.5x tie tolerance are Probe's starting values.

  4. FiducialMissingmajorOpen

    FiducialMissing: 2 boards×2

    2 checked by the review by evaluation@esharp.se — 2 different reasons

    At bottom, top

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • bottomThe bottom side carries 86 SMT component(s) and no fiducial was found on it

      The bottom side carries 86 SMT component(s) but no fiducial was found on it — a placement machine has no optical reference to align to. Probe found no pad labelled .pad_usage=g_fiducial/l_fiducial (basis pad_usage); no single-pad, netless, undrilled component whose 0.5-3 mm round pad has a concentric solder-mask opening at least 1.5x its diameter with no other copper inside it (basis geometry); and no component whose refdes starts FID or whose part or package name contains FIDUCIAL (basis footprint-name). If your library names fiducials something Probe does not recognise, mark this benign — disposition_finding(rule='FiducialMissing', entity='bottom', status='benign', reason=…) — the name match only ever silences this check, it never asserts anything. If the side really has no fiducial, say so with status='confirmed': that answers the finding and keeps it gating release.

    • topThe top side carries 100 SMT component(s) and no fiducial was found on it

      The top side carries 100 SMT component(s) but no fiducial was found on it — a placement machine has no optical reference to align to. Probe found no pad labelled .pad_usage=g_fiducial/l_fiducial (basis pad_usage); no single-pad, netless, undrilled component whose 0.5-3 mm round pad has a concentric solder-mask opening at least 1.5x its diameter with no other copper inside it (basis geometry); and no component whose refdes starts FID or whose part or package name contains FIDUCIAL (basis footprint-name). If your library names fiducials something Probe does not recognise, mark this benign — disposition_finding(rule='FiducialMissing', entity='top', status='benign', reason=…) — the name match only ever silences this check, it never asserts anything. If the side really has no fiducial, say so with status='confirmed': that answers the finding and keeps it gating release.

  5. PartLifecyclemajorOpen

    PartLifecycle: 3 part numbers×3

    2 Obsolete, 1 Not For New Designs · on 3 placements

    At IC3, IC5, U4

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • IC3LP5951MF-3.0/NOPB on IC3: the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for National Semiconductor's LP5951MF-3.0/NOPB

      LP5951MF-3.0/NOPB on IC3: the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for National Semiconductor's LP5951MF-3.0/NOPB — a sourcing/longevity risk to confirm against the MANUFACTURER before acting. That is the maker this board's BOM names (NATIONAL SEMICONDUCTOR). A distributor delisting is not the same claim as the part being unavailable; check the vendor's own lifecycle/product-change notice for the status and any named successor. Re-read the source: GET /api/odb/parts/LP5951MF-3.0/NOPB/providers (which provider said it, the maker and part number it matched, its own words, and when we asked). No approved alternate is recorded for this position.

    • IC5CP2102-GM on IC5: the distributor catalogue reports "Not For New Designs" for Silicon Labs's CP2102-GM

      CP2102-GM on IC5: the distributor catalogue reports "Not For New Designs" for Silicon Labs's CP2102-GM — a sourcing/longevity risk to confirm against the MANUFACTURER before acting. This board's BOM names no manufacturer for it, so whether that is the fitted maker's product was not checked. A distributor delisting is not the same claim as the part being unavailable; check the vendor's own lifecycle/product-change notice for the status and any named successor. Re-read the source: GET /api/odb/parts/CP2102-GM/providers (which provider said it, the maker and part number it matched, its own words, and when we asked). No approved alternate is recorded for this position.

    • U4NLSX5014DTR2G on U4: the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for onsemi's NLSX5014DTR2G

      NLSX5014DTR2G on U4: the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for onsemi's NLSX5014DTR2G — a sourcing/longevity risk to confirm against the MANUFACTURER before acting. This board's BOM names no manufacturer for it, so whether that is the fitted maker's product was not checked. A distributor delisting is not the same claim as the part being unavailable; check the vendor's own lifecycle/product-change notice for the status and any named successor. Re-read the source: GET /api/odb/parts/NLSX5014DTR2G/providers (which provider said it, the maker and part number it matched, its own words, and when we asked). THE LAST BUY DATE HAS PASSED (2023-11-20, 1,091 day(s) ago), so this is a substitution rather than a buy. The distributor reports NONE left. No approved alternate is recorded for this position.

  6. observationOBS-368minorOpen

    D1 3.3 V zener clamp on the 3.3 V rail conducts ~100 mA at the nominal operating voltage

    Zener D1 (1SMB5913, 3.3 V) sits directly across the 3.3 V rail P3V3, and at the nominal rail voltage it is at its own test point, so it sinks on the order of 100 mA continuously instead of clamping above the operating range.

    Where it is

    D1 has cathode on P3V3 and anode on GND, downstream of fuse F1 (which feeds P3V3 from P3V3_AUX).

    The numbers

    QuantityValueSource
    VZ min / nom / max3.13 / 3.3 / 3.47 V1SMB5913B datasheet, p.4
    Test current IZT113.6 mA1SMB5913B datasheet, p.4
    ZZT10 ohm1SMB5913B datasheet, p.4
    Rail nominal3.3 Vnetlist: P3V3
    Standing current, typical parton the order of 100 mA, roughly 0.4 Wstatement

    A low-tolerance part (3.13 V) sinks more, and on a 3.3 V source at the high end of its tolerance the current rises further.

    Why it matters

    The clamp acts as a shunt load/regulator on the main rail rather than an overvoltage clamp above the operating range. It wastes supply budget, heats D1, and pulls the rail toward the zener's own voltage.

  7. observationOBS-377minorOpen

    FMC pair LA06 lands P/N-swapped on the FPGA (LA06_P on IO_L63N_2, LA06_N on IO_L63P_2)

    FMC pair LA06 lands P/N-swapped on the FPGA U1: LA06_P on ball V4 (IO_L63N_2) and LA06_N on ball T4 (IO_L63P_2). Differential use needs inversion in the FPGA design.

    J1 contactNetU1 ballBall functionSource
    C10LA06_PV4IO_L63N_2netlist; UG385 Table 2-8, p.83
    C11LA06_NT4IO_L63P_2netlist; UG385 Table 2-8, p.83
    • Every other LA pair on J1 lands P-to-P and N-to-N.
    • If LA06 is used as a differential pair (LVDS input or output), the FPGA design must invert the signal, and a user-supplied mezzanine/carrier pin map will read inverted data unless this is documented.
    • Single-ended use is unaffected.
  8. observationOBS-378minorOpen

    EEPROM IC9 address pins A0/A1 are driven only by the FMC GA lines, with no local pull: address undefined when the board runs without a carrier

    EEPROM IC9 (24AA64) address pins A0/A1 are driven only by the FMC GA lines, with no local pull, so the EEPROM address is undefined when the board runs without a carrier.

    Where it is

    IC9 pinNetOther connectionPullSource
    1, A0GA1J1 D35nonenetlist: net GA1
    2, A1GA0J1 C34nonenetlist: net GA0

    The 24AA64 datasheet requires the address inputs to be connected to VCC or VSS (section 2.1, p.6).

    Why it matters

    • With an FMC carrier, the carrier defines GA0/GA1.
    • The schematic states the board can also run from its own supply ("The CUTE-WR can be powered either from FMC or Power Jack"). Then U1 still reaches IC9 over EEPROM_SCL/SDA (K17/J18) while A0/A1 float, so the EEPROM's address is undefined and may change with noise.

    Also noted

    A0 takes GA1 and A1 takes GA0, the reverse of the pin-for-pin order. Worth confirming against the FMC geographic-address convention the software expects.

  9. observationOBS-379minorOpen

    No fiducials in the board data for a double-sided assembly with a 0.8 mm-pitch BGA

    No fiducials in the board data, for a double-sided assembly with a 0.8 mm-pitch BGA (U1, XC6SLX45T CSG324) on top and 0402 decoupling under it.

    • The placement data holds 196 parts: 109 top, 87 bottom.
    • No pad carries a fiducial usage attribute, and no component reads as a fiducial by refdes or part name.
    • Neither global nor local fiducials are present on either side of the board as exported.
  10. observationOBS-380minorOpen

    No test points on the board: rails, resets and configuration nets have no dedicated probe access

    No test points on the board: rails, resets and FPGA configuration nets have no dedicated probe access.

    There are no test-point components or test pads (no TP-class refdes among the 196 placed parts).

    Without a probe point:

    • Power rails: P3V3, 1.5V, P1V2, P3V3_CLEAN, OSC2VS, MGT_AVC_A
    • FPGA configuration nets: FPGA_DONE, FPGA_PROGRAM_B, INIT_B (NetR6_2)
    • The clock nets

    Bring-up access is limited to JTAG header J2, the USB-UART J5, the SMA/LEMO CLK and PPS jacks, and component pads.

  11. observationOBS-382minorOpen

    Run-together reference designators on the silkscreen (R20R18, R5R17, C58C50, C34C32C26) make several positions ambiguous

    Several neighbouring designators are printed edge to edge on the silkscreen (R20R18, R5R17, C58C50, C34C32C26), so they read as one string and make positions ambiguous, including the CDCM61004 clock strap jumpers.

    SideRun-together designatorsWhere
    top"R20R18", "R5R17"next to IC2, the CDCM61004 strap jumpers
    top"C104 C105"beside U4
    bottom"C58C50", "C34C32C26", "C51C61"under U1
    bottom"C114"/"C113" stackedbetween the decoupler rows
    • Text height measured on the render is about 0.6 mm (for example "C113" ~70 px at 120 px/mm), with ~0.1 mm stroke.
    • The CDCM61004 strap positions R5/R17/R18/R20/R27/R28/R29 are three-pad selector footprints, where knowing which designator is which matters for setting the clock configuration.

Main parts

Part numberMakerDescriptionWhere
0154003.DRLITTELFUSEFuseF1
1SMB5913(3.3V)Zener DiodeD1
24AA64T-I/MCMICROCHIP TECHNOLOGY1.7-5.5V 64K I2C Serial EEPROMIC9
AD5663BRMZ16bit DACIC4
ASP-134488-01SAMTECConnector VITA 57, 160 Male contacts in 4 row cdghJ1
CDCM61004RHBTTEXAS INSTRUMENTSFour Output, Integrated VCO, Low-Jitter Clock GeneratorIC2
CP2102-GMIC5
DS18B20U+DALLAS MAXIMProgrammable Resolution 1-Wire Digital ThermometerIC12
JTAGHDR2X5J2
LF VCXO026156IQD FREQUENCY PRODUCTSOSC_20MHZ_IQD_LF VCXO026156OSC3
LM4040B25IDBZ2.5V Reference VoltageIC6
LP5951MF-3.0/NOPBNATIONAL SEMICONDUCTOR3V, 150mA Micropower Low-Dropout CMOS Voltage RegulatorIC3
M25P32-VMW6FlashIC8
NLSX5014DTR2G4-Bit 100Mb/s Configurable Dual-Supply Level TranslatorU4
PRTR5V0U2XPHILIPS NXPUltra Low Capacitance Double Rail-to-Rail ESD Protection DiodeIC11
TPS62130RGTU2
TPS7A7300RGWU3
USB UARTJ5
VM53S3-25.000-2.5/-30+75MERCURY ELECTRONICSOSC_25MHZ_MERCURY_VM53S3-25.000-2.5/-30+75OSC2
WR SFP0Tyco-1367073-1, Tyco-1489779-1J4
WR SFP1Tyco-1367073-1, Tyco-1489779-1J6
XC6SLX45T-3CSG324CSpartan-6 LXT 1.2V FPGA, 190 User I/Os, 324-Ball Chip-Scale BGA (0.8mm Pitch), Speed Grade 3, Commercial Grade, Pb-FreeU1
LEDSMD LEDLED0, LED1, LED2
4.7K_ArrayResistor Array (0603)RP0, RP1

About this design

Design
CUTE WR DP — OHWR0031 R1
Designed in
Altium Designer
Board
8 copper layers, 76.5 × 69 mm, 196 components, 208 nets
Licence
CERN-OHL-1.1
Source
https://gitlab.com/ohwr/project/cute-wr-dp at commit 09712b471ea3
Attribution
CERN Open Hardware Repository, project ohwr/project/cute-wr-dp (commit 09712b471ea3096712e2ca370e3b1764ebd003fd, 2025-04-09). Licence: CERN-OHL-1.1 (stated on the schematic sheets). Source: https://gitlab.com/ohwr/project/cute-wr-dp. This is a snapshot of the copy published on the OHWR GitLab pages (R1), not CERN's released record. CERN's source of truth is EDMS (https://edms.cern.ch), and the current release may be newer.
Reviewed with
Probe by E# (E-Sharp AB)