DIOT CRATE FRONT INTERFACE
OHWR0086 · revision R5
DIOT CRATE FRONT INTERFACE (OHWR0086 R5) is an open-hardware circuit board from its public repository, designed in Altium Designer: a 4-layer board of 217.4 × 100 mm with 14 components and 30 nets, published under CERN-OHL-W-2.0.
review complete · 1 item need the designer's input · 4 findings: 1 major · 3 minor (7 items)
Open in the interactive viewerRead the full review

Design review
Probe recorded 4 findings: 1 major · 3 minor (7 items) on this design. Each is shown here with its reasoning; the full review links every one to the pins, nets and datasheet pages it rests on.
- ReferencePlaneDiscontinuitymajorOpen
2 nets change reference between GND and P12V0 at 4 vias, none with a reference that continues across (fastest: PS_ON_N at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)
At 4 via(s), on 2 net(s), the signal leaves a layer referenced by one of GND and P12V0 for a layer referenced by the other, and no plane references both layers. Different nets: no via can carry the return across; only decoupling between the two planes near the via can. The capacitor carrying the return across was measured at each via, at the knee of the crossing net's edge against 50 ohm assumed: 4 with none. 4 of them at an ASSUMED edge (no edge on file for the net): state one (net_timing_state) and it is re-read. One decision covers the pair: whether GND and P12V0 are decoupled to each other near these vias. A via whose layers have more references than these two is a site of each pair it joins. None is partial: at every one, no reference continues across the via.
- 'M_SCL' at (130.9, 101.95), L2 -> L3: P12V0 on TOP_LAYER to GND on BOTTOM_LAYER; pure, no reference continues across; stitching none, 192.6 mm of track past the via on L3: At the 5 GHz knee of a 100 ps edge (10 ns 10-90 %, assumed: no edge is on file for the net) no capacitor carries the return; only the planes do. GND and P12V0 are not a thin pair (at most 0.2 mm), so their own capacitance does not carry the return. To serve it, change layers across the same plane, or move the signal to a layer referenced to ground. None.
- 'M_SCL' at (146.61, 101.92), L2 -> L3: P12V0 on TOP_LAYER to GND on BOTTOM_LAYER; pure, no reference continues across; stitching none, 192.6 mm of track past the via on L3: At the 5 GHz knee of a 100 ps edge (10 ns 10-90 %, assumed: no edge is on file for the net) no capacitor carries the return; only the planes do. GND and P12V0 are not a thin pair (at most 0.2 mm), so their own capacitance does not carry the return. To serve it, change layers across the same plane, or move the signal to a layer referenced to ground. None.
- 'PS_ON_N' at (127, 98.1), L2 -> L3: P12V0 on TOP_LAYER to GND on BOTTOM_LAYER; pure, no reference continues across; stitching none, 124.5 mm of track past the via on L3: At the 5 GHz knee of a 100 ps edge (100 ps 10-90 %, assumed: no edge is on file for the net) no capacitor carries the return; only the planes do. GND and P12V0 are not a thin pair (at most 0.2 mm), so their own capacitance does not carry the return. To serve it, change layers across the same plane, or move the signal to a layer referenced to ground. None.
- 'PS_ON_N' at (163.2, 108), L2 -> L3: P12V0 on TOP_LAYER to P5V on L2, GND on BOTTOM_LAYER; pure, no reference continues across; stitching none, 124.5 mm of track past the via on L3: At the 5 GHz knee of a 100 ps edge (100 ps 10-90 %, assumed: no edge is on file for the net) no capacitor carries the return; only the planes do. GND and P12V0 are not a thin pair (at most 0.2 mm), so their own capacitance does not carry the return. To serve it, change layers across the same plane, or move the signal to a layer referenced to ground. None.
Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/90/reference-planes?group=refchange%3AGND%7CP12V0 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 125..165.2, y 96.1..110 mm (board frame, Y up).
The reference on each layer is the first plane the track meets leaving the via, anti-pads and the net's own copper skipped. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.
At refchange:GND|P12V0
Utility connector pin 14 is documented BNC_RST- but no board wires it: the BNC reset pulse returns through PE
The Power Backplane Utility connector table assigns lower Molex pin 14 to BNC_RST-, but J2 pin 14 is unconnected on the Front Interface (and on the Power Backplane's J4.14); the BNC power-cycle pulse actually returns through protective earth (PE). The table describes a return conductor that does not exist.
What the copper does
``
mermaid flowchart LR BNC["J4 BNC centre (BNC_RST+)"] --> J2_13["FI J2.13 = PBP J4.13"] --> PBP["PBP J5/J6 A1"] --> COIL["AC Input RL1 coil A1 (via R1 10R)"] COIL --> A2["RL1 coil A2 = PE"] SHELL["J4 BNC shell = PE"] --- A2``Item Documented Copper Source Lower Molex pin 13 BNC_RST+ BNC_RST+ netlist: net BNC_RST+ Lower Molex pin 14 BNC_RST- not connected (J2.14 and PBP J4.14) netlist: component J2 Lower Molex pins 15, 16 PE PE netlist: net PE BNC shell "outer shield as ground" (spec 3.3.1) PE (spec 3.3 item 5: outer coupled to chassis for EMC) netlist: net PE Why it matters
The design is self-consistent (24 V pulse referenced to PE, relay coil returned to PE on the AC Input Module), so the crate works. But Table 4, which also appears on this board's own drawing, names a BNC_RST- contact that a module designer would reasonably wire as the coil return; nothing on the Power Backplane carries it. CERN to confirm whether pin 14 should be marked unused (return via PE) in Table 4.
Crate spec v3.1 Table 6 still calls Aux D-SUB15 pins 2, 4 and 9 "reserved"; the board carries fused +12 V and PS_ON_N there by design (crate-hw #114)
The front-panel Aux D-SUB15 (J5 lower) carries fused +12 V on pins 2 and 4 and the crate's PS_ON_N on pin 9, as CERN intended (diot-crate-hw #114). The DI/OT Crate specification v3.1, Table 6, still documents all three pins as "reserved", so a user wiring the Aux port from the specification can load the 12 V branch or pull the crate's power-on line.
Specification against copper
Aux pin DI/OT Crate spec v3.1, Table 6 OHWR0086 R5 copper Source 2 reserved NetF1_2 = P12V0 through F1 (4 A) netlist: J5 contact L2 4 reserved NetF1_2 = P12V0 through F1 (4 A) netlist: J5 contact L4 9 reserved PS_ON_N (crate PSU enable, also on J2.3 and J3.D3) netlist: J5 contact L9 11 5V NetF2_2 = P5V through F2 (2 A) netlist: J5 contact L11 Design intent
CERN's [diot-crate-hw #114](https://gitlab.com/ohwr/project/diot-crate-hw/-/issues/114), "add 12V and PS_ON_N to the Front Interface Module AUX connector" (closed, Done, crate v3): "L2, L4 connected to 12V; L9 connected to PS_ON_N", keeping voltage compatibility with the Fan Tray connector in case of an accidental swap. The board implements exactly that.
What to change
Update spec Table 6 to name pins 2 and 4 as +12 V (shared 4 A fused branch with the fan tray) and pin 9 as PS_ON_N. The Fan Tray D-SUB (J5 upper) already matches its Table 5.
- ReferencePlaneDiscontinuityminorOpen
ReferencePlaneDiscontinuity: 4 boards×4
Checked by the review, stands · Claude walker V2 (cern-01 session) — Post-0.529.0 verify, 5 findings. Warning tier: BNC_RST+ runs 75.7 mm along the P5V/PE split on L2, with GND on BOTTOM_LAYER carrying most of the return; it is a front-panel reset input. M_SCL (I2C management bus) and PS_ON_N (supply enable) change reference P12V0 to GND at 4 vias with no stitching cap. Info tier: F_IO0/1, F_RST, M_SCL/M_SDA, PRST_N, PS_ON_N, PWRBTN_N. None is a clock, a high-speed pair or a converter control line. All are slow or static (resets, enables, push-button, I2C <=400 kHz). The rule's 100 ps edge is assumed: no edge is on file for these nets. The finding stands as layout practice; no observation is warranted.
At along@L2:P5V|PE, refchange:P12V0|P5V, void:P5V@L2:192.93,89.95, void:routed@L2|L3
Each finding, with its own headline
along@L2:P5V|PE'BNC_RST+' runs ALONG the split between the P5V and PE planes on L2 at 1 place, the longest 75.73 mm; the impedance there is not said (fastest: BNC_RST+ at 20 ns 10-90 %, suggested by its name)
On L2 the P5V and PE planes part, and 'BNC_RST+' runs down the slot between them at 1 place(s), rather than across it. This is not a crossing: the return still follows the track, in the plane on its other side and in the slot's edges, so it does not detour. What changes is the track's own impedance. With the plane gone from under it on this side for that length, its field reaches further, to the slot's edges and to the next plane beyond, so its capacitance falls and its impedance rises; every edge travelling down it is partly reflected where it enters the stretch and again where it leaves, by (Z2 - Z1)/(Z2 + Z1). The longer the stretch against the edge's rise, the more of the edge sees the full step. A crossing is generally the worse fault; a mismatch is not free. At 1 place(s) the impedance cannot be said: the slot's two edges were not both read beside the track. No place stays within 10 %, the tolerance controlled impedance is commonly built to (the stackup states none), so the finding is a warning. One decision covers the split line's slot: whether these tracks may run down it, or should be moved over solid plane.
- 'BNC_RST+' on L3 at (173.5, 143.25), 140.31 mm, running ALONG the split for 75.73 mm, not across it, impedance not said: the slot's two edges were not both read beside the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/90/reference-planes?group=along%40L2%3AP5V%7CPE serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 106.56..234.33, y 124.7..161.81 mm (board frame, Y up).
Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.
refchange:P12V0|P5V'PS_ON_N' changes reference between P12V0 and P5V at a via, none with a reference that continues across (fastest: PS_ON_N at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)
At 1 via(s), on 1 net(s), the signal leaves a layer referenced by one of P12V0 and P5V for a layer referenced by the other, and no plane references both layers. Different nets: no via can carry the return across; only decoupling between the two planes near the via can. The capacitor carrying the return across was measured at each via, at the knee of the crossing net's edge against 50 ohm assumed: 1 served. Every site is served, so the finding is the lower tier (info). 1 of them at an ASSUMED edge (no edge on file for the net): state one (net_timing_state) and it is re-read. One decision covers the pair: whether P12V0 and P5V are decoupled to each other near these vias. A via whose layers have more references than these two is a site of each pair it joins. None is partial: at every one, no reference continues across the via.
- 'PS_ON_N' at (163.2, 108), L2 -> L3: P12V0 on TOP_LAYER to P5V on L2, GND on BOTTOM_LAYER; pure, no reference continues across; stitching served, 124.5 mm of track past the via on L3: At the 5 GHz knee of a 100 ps edge (100 ps 10-90 %, assumed: no edge is on file for the net) no capacitor carries the return; only the planes do. P12V0 on TOP_LAYER and P5V on L2 are adjacent, 0.180 mm apart: their own capacitance carries the return. Served.
Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/90/reference-planes?group=refchange%3AP12V0%7CP5V serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 161.2..165.2, y 106..110 mm (board frame, Y up).
The reference on each layer is the first plane the track meets leaving the via, anti-pads and the net's own copper skipped. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.
void:P5V@L2:192.93,89.95'PRST_N' crosses where the outline of the P5V plane on L2 is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 88.1 mm (fastest: PRST_N at 20 ns 10-90 %, suggested by its name)
Along 'PRST_N' on L3, the P5V plane on L2 has 88.1 mm under the track with no copper, at (192.93, 89.95), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. 1 of them run ALONG the bare copper, parallel to its edges, rather than across it (the longest 83.05 mm). No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 129.75..306.17, y 86.95..136.29 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. Every crossing has a plane on the track's other side at most twice as far away as the broken one, so at most 15% of the return meets the break and the rest follows the track on that plane (to first order each plane beside a stripline carries a share of the return inversely proportional to its distance from the track). The finding is the lower tier (info).
- 'PRST_N' on L3 at (192.93, 89.95), 88.1 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 83.05 mm, not across it over no copper; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/90/reference-planes?group=void%3AP5V%40L2%3A192.93%2C89.95 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 147.28..236.53, y 88.95..93 mm (board frame, Y up).
Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.
void:routed@L2|L38 nets on L3 cross the tracks routed through the P5V pour on L2 at 15 places, the longest 139.29 mm; 14 run ALONG the cut round another net's track (fastest: PS_ON_N at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)
The P5V pour on L2 is cleared round tracks routed through it, and tracks on L3, which take that pour as their reference, cross them: for the width of each cut the return has no plane under it and detours round the cut. 15 place(s) on 8 net(s). 14 of the crossings run ALONG the cut round another net's track rather than across it, parallel to its edges (the longest 127.17 mm): over or right beside that track, broadside to it as well as off the plane. One decision covers the layer pair: whether these layers may take a pour their own tracks cut as the reference, or the routing or the stackup should give the tracks a plane that is not cut where they cross. Every crossing has a plane on the track's other side at most twice as far away as the broken one, so at most 15% of the return meets the break and the rest follows the track on that plane (to first order each plane beside a stripline carries a share of the return inversely proportional to its distance from the track). The finding is the lower tier (info).
- 'M_SDA' on L3 at (194.46, 104.95), 139.29 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 122.05 mm, not across it over copper of PS_ON_N, not a plane, to the end of the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'F_IO0' on L3 at (193.95, 98.87), 133.86 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 127.17 mm, not across it over copper of M_SCL, PS_ON_N, not a plane, to the end of the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'F_IO1' on L3 at (193.43, 119.95), 131.26 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 115.64 mm, not across it over copper of PE, not a plane, to the end of the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'M_SCL' on L3 at (193.95, 101.92), 85.72 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 83.13 mm, not across it over copper of PS_ON_N, not a plane, to the end of the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'PRST_N' on L3 at (258.95, 93.2), 71.21 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 27.42 mm, not across it over copper of P_IO1, P_PRES1, P_PRES0, not a plane, to the end of the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'PRST_N' on L3 at (118.7, 108.74), 53.99 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 35.47 mm, not across it over copper of M_SCL, PS_ON_N, not a plane, to the end of the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'PWRBTN_N' on L3 at (117.85, 105.97), 50.49 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 30.59 mm, not across it over copper of NetF2_2, M_SCL, PS_ON_N, not a plane, to the end of the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'F_IO0' on L3 at (248.83, 98.87), 49.86 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 14.12 mm, not across it over copper of P_IO1, P_PRES1, P_PRES0, PWRFAIL_N, PS_ON_N, P12V_Sense, RTN_Sense, not a plane; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'M_SCL' on L3 at (271.17, 118.66), 45.69 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 14.21 mm, not across it over copper of P_PRES1, P_PRES0, PWRFAIL_N, PS_ON_N, P12V_Sense, RTN_Sense, not a plane; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'M_SDA' on L3 at (266.54, 118.66), 39.82 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 9.88 mm, not across it over copper of P_PRES1, P_PRES0, PWRFAIL_N, PS_ON_N, P12V_Sense, RTN_Sense, not a plane; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'F_RST' on L3 at (117, 100.51), 27.73 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 22.68 mm, not across it over copper of PS_ON_N, not a plane, to the end of the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- 'PS_ON_N' on L3 at (243.41, 108), 14.54 mm, running ALONG the bare copper for 3.7 mm, not across it over copper of P_PRES0, PWRFAIL_N, not a plane, to the end of the track; other side: GND on BOTTOM_LAYER, 0.18 mm from the track against 1 mm to L2: 15% of the return on L2
- and 3 more
Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/90/reference-planes?group=void%3Arouted%40L2%7CL3 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 94.5..305.24, y 88.95..128.69 mm (board frame, Y up).
Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.
Main parts
| Part number | Maker | Description | Where |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0453002. | LITTELFUSE | Fuse | F2 |
| 0453004. | LITTELFUSE | Fuse | F1 |
| 51939-667 | AMPHENOL | Thru-Hole, Lead 3.43mm, PowerBlade Right Angled Power Connector 3ACP 2P 24S 4P Contacts | J3 |
| 73099-0 | POMONA | Single Terminal Socket | B1 |
| 73101-0120 | MOLEX | J4 | |
| L17H2440121 | AMPHENOL | Connector D-sub 2x15 Female | J5 |
| R0805_1M_1%_0.125W_100PPM | GENERIC | Resistor - 1% | R1 |
| 44428-2402 | MOLEX | Connector 24 Male | J1, J2 |
| Use only in PCB | Fiducial Target | FTG1, FTG2, FTG3 |
About this design
- Design
- DIOT CRATE FRONT INTERFACE — OHWR0086 R5
- Designed in
- Altium Designer
- Board
- 4 copper layers, 217.4 × 100 mm, 14 components, 30 nets
- Licence
- CERN-OHL-W-2.0
- Source
- https://edms.cern.ch/item/EDA-04213-V5-0/0 at commit
EDMS EDA-042 - Attribution
- CERN EDMS item EDA-04213-V5-0 'DI/OT Crate - Front Interface': document 3172964 v.1, retrieved 2026-10-18T13:03:24Z. CERN EDA-04213 V5, DI/OT Crate - Front Interface. Copyright CERN 2023. Licence: CERN OHL-W v2.0+. Project: https://gitlab.com/ohwr/project/diot-crate-hw
- Reviewed with
- Probe by E# (E-Sharp AB)