Probe E# — E-Sharp AB
Probe is made by E# (E-Sharp AB) in Sweden. Want your own boards reviewed like this? Book a meeting

FDA 8CH

OHWR0069 · revision R1

FDA 8CH (OHWR0069 R1) is an open-hardware circuit board from the CERN Open Hardware Repository, designed in KiCad EDA: a 2-layer board of 170 × 70 mm with 416 components and 134 nets, published under CERN-OHL-1.2.

review 92% walked · 9 findings: 1 blocker · 5 major · 3 minor (19 items)

Open in the interactive viewerRead the full review

FDA 8CH (OHWR0069 R1) circuit board, top view: copper, silkscreen and components
Top view, rendered by Probe from the design's own fabrication data.

Design review

Probe recorded 9 findings: 1 blocker · 5 major · 3 minor (19 items) on this design. Each is shown here with its reasoning; the full review links every one to the pins, nets and datasheet pages it rests on.

  1. PowerRailConflictblockerOpen

    P901 bridges different-voltage rails: Vin_POS (9V), Vin_NEG (-9V)

    P901 (3-pin part) bridges different-voltage rails: Vin_POS (9V), Vin_NEG (-9V) — rail-to-rail short?

    At P901

  2. CapVoltageDeratingmajorOpen

    C906 sits on a 8.5 V rail and its voltage rating is not in the BOM

    C906: on a 8.5 V rail but its voltage rating is not stated in the BOM — add it so the rating can be compared to the rail at all. No datasheet is on file for this part; the BOM short-spec is the source.

    At C906

  3. CapVoltageDeratingmajorOpen

    C908 sits on a 8.5 V rail and its voltage rating is not in the BOM

    C908: on a 8.5 V rail but its voltage rating is not stated in the BOM — add it so the rating can be compared to the rail at all. No datasheet is on file for this part; the BOM short-spec is the source.

    At C908

  4. CapVoltageDeratingmajorOpen

    CapVoltageDerating: 2 components×2

    e.g. “C905 sits on a 9 V rail and its voltage rating is not in the BOM”

    At C905, C907

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • C905C905 sits on a 9 V rail and its voltage rating is not in the BOM

      C905: on a 9 V rail but its voltage rating is not stated in the BOM — add it so the rating can be compared to the rail at all. No datasheet is on file for this part; the BOM short-spec is the source. 'Net-(C905-Pad1)' sits at -9 V; a voltage rating is a magnitude, so it is judged at 9 V.

    • C907C907 sits on a 9 V rail and its voltage rating is not in the BOM

      C907: on a 9 V rail but its voltage rating is not stated in the BOM — add it so the rating can be compared to the rail at all. No datasheet is on file for this part; the BOM short-spec is the source. 'LDO_IN_NEG' sits at -9 V; a voltage rating is a magnitude, so it is judged at 9 V.

  5. ReferencePlaneDiscontinuitymajorOpen

    ReferencePlaneDiscontinuity: 10 boards×10

    Checked by the review, stands · Claude walker W1 (Cern session) — Checked: the GND-pour cut-backs (1.02 mm, one per channel input) and routed crossings read from the copper stand. They sit on the channel input coupling nets; no datasheet or app note on file sets a limit, and the crossings are millimetre-scale against the amplifier band. Left for the owner.

    At void:GND@B.CU:103,-73.2, void:GND@B.CU:119,-73.2, void:GND@B.CU:135,-73.2, void:GND@B.CU:151,-73.2, void:GND@B.CU:167,-73.2, void:GND@B.CU:183,-73.2 and 4 more

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • void:GND@B.CU:103,-73.2'Net-(C301-Pad2)' crosses where the outline of the GND plane on B.CU is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 1.02 mm (fastest: Net-(C301-Pad2) at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      Along 'Net-(C301-Pad2)' on F.CU, the GND plane on B.CU has 1.02 mm under the track with no copper, at (103, -73.2), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 50.05..219.95, y -132.95..-63.05 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(C301-Pad2)' on F.CU at (103, -73.2), 1.02 mm over no copper; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3AGND%40B.CU%3A103%2C-73.2 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 102..104, y -77.46..-71.94 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:GND@B.CU:119,-73.2'Net-(C401-Pad2)' crosses where the outline of the GND plane on B.CU is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 1.02 mm (fastest: Net-(C401-Pad2) at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      Along 'Net-(C401-Pad2)' on F.CU, the GND plane on B.CU has 1.02 mm under the track with no copper, at (119, -73.2), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 50.05..219.95, y -132.95..-63.05 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(C401-Pad2)' on F.CU at (119, -73.2), 1.02 mm over no copper; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3AGND%40B.CU%3A119%2C-73.2 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 118..120, y -77.46..-71.94 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:GND@B.CU:135,-73.2'Net-(C501-Pad2)' crosses where the outline of the GND plane on B.CU is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 1.02 mm (fastest: Net-(C501-Pad2) at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      Along 'Net-(C501-Pad2)' on F.CU, the GND plane on B.CU has 1.02 mm under the track with no copper, at (135, -73.2), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 50.05..219.95, y -132.95..-63.05 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(C501-Pad2)' on F.CU at (135, -73.2), 1.02 mm over no copper; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3AGND%40B.CU%3A135%2C-73.2 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 134..136, y -77.46..-71.94 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:GND@B.CU:151,-73.2'Net-(C601-Pad2)' crosses where the outline of the GND plane on B.CU is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 1.02 mm (fastest: Net-(C601-Pad2) at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      Along 'Net-(C601-Pad2)' on F.CU, the GND plane on B.CU has 1.02 mm under the track with no copper, at (151, -73.2), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 50.05..219.95, y -132.95..-63.05 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(C601-Pad2)' on F.CU at (151, -73.2), 1.02 mm over no copper; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3AGND%40B.CU%3A151%2C-73.2 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 150..152, y -77.46..-71.94 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:GND@B.CU:167,-73.2'Net-(C701-Pad2)' crosses where the outline of the GND plane on B.CU is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 1.02 mm (fastest: Net-(C701-Pad2) at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      Along 'Net-(C701-Pad2)' on F.CU, the GND plane on B.CU has 1.02 mm under the track with no copper, at (167, -73.2), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 50.05..219.95, y -132.95..-63.05 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(C701-Pad2)' on F.CU at (167, -73.2), 1.02 mm over no copper; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3AGND%40B.CU%3A167%2C-73.2 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 166..168, y -77.46..-71.94 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:GND@B.CU:183,-73.2'Net-(C801-Pad2)' crosses where the outline of the GND plane on B.CU is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 1.02 mm (fastest: Net-(C801-Pad2) at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      Along 'Net-(C801-Pad2)' on F.CU, the GND plane on B.CU has 1.02 mm under the track with no copper, at (183, -73.2), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 50.05..219.95, y -132.95..-63.05 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(C801-Pad2)' on F.CU at (183, -73.2), 1.02 mm over no copper; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3AGND%40B.CU%3A183%2C-73.2 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 182..184, y -77.46..-71.94 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:GND@B.CU:199,-73.2'Net-(C1001-Pad2)' crosses where the outline of the GND plane on B.CU is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 1.02 mm (fastest: Net-(C1001-Pad2) at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      Along 'Net-(C1001-Pad2)' on F.CU, the GND plane on B.CU has 1.02 mm under the track with no copper, at (199, -73.2), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 50.05..219.95, y -132.95..-63.05 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(C1001-Pad2)' on F.CU at (199, -73.2), 1.02 mm over no copper; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3AGND%40B.CU%3A199%2C-73.2 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 198..200, y -77.46..-71.94 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:GND@B.CU:71,-73.2'Net-(C101-Pad2)' crosses where the outline of the GND plane on B.CU is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 1.02 mm (fastest: Net-(C101-Pad2) at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      Along 'Net-(C101-Pad2)' on F.CU, the GND plane on B.CU has 1.02 mm under the track with no copper, at (71, -73.2), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 50.05..219.95, y -132.95..-63.05 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(C101-Pad2)' on F.CU at (71, -73.2), 1.02 mm over no copper; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3AGND%40B.CU%3A71%2C-73.2 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 70..72, y -77.46..-71.94 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:GND@B.CU:87,-73.2'Net-(C201-Pad2)' crosses where the outline of the GND plane on B.CU is drawn back, at 1 place, the longest 1.02 mm (fastest: Net-(C201-Pad2) at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      Along 'Net-(C201-Pad2)' on F.CU, the GND plane on B.CU has 1.02 mm under the track with no copper, at (87, -73.2), the same plane on both sides. No single drill's anti-pad and no landing explains it: a clearance is excused only when it holds a drill and is drawn round it, or the track ends in it on the net's own pad or via, or runs through its own via's clearance and no farther. The return current detours round the void. No hole cleared it: the outline of the pour at x 50.05..219.95, y -132.95..-63.05 is drawn back there. One decision covers the void: whether these tracks may cross it, or the plane should be filled under them. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(C201-Pad2)' on F.CU at (87, -73.2), 1.02 mm over no copper; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3AGND%40B.CU%3A87%2C-73.2 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 86..88, y -77.46..-71.94 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:routed@B.CU|F.CU3 nets on F.CU cross the tracks routed through the GND pour on B.CU at 17 places, the longest 1.89 mm (fastest: /out1/Input at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      The GND pour on B.CU is cleared round tracks routed through it, and tracks on F.CU, which take that pour as their reference, cross them: for the width of each cut the return has no plane under it and detours round the cut. 17 place(s) on 3 net(s). One decision covers the layer pair: whether these layers may take a pour their own tracks cut as the reference, or the routing or the stackup should give the tracks a plane that is not cut where they cross. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • 'Net-(R901-Pad2)' on F.CU at (77.43, -119.57), 1.89 mm over copper of +6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (108.57, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of -6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (111.43, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of +6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (124.57, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of -6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (127.43, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of +6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (140.57, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of -6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (142.57, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of +6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (156.57, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of -6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (158.57, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of +6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (172.57, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of -6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (174.57, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of +6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/out1/Input' on F.CU at (188.57, -102), 1.36 mm over copper of -6V, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • and 5 more

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/70/reference-planes?group=void%3Arouted%40B.CU%7CF.CU serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 75.32..196.18, y -126.7..-101 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

  6. FiducialMissingmajorOpen

    The top side carries 193 SMT component(s) and no fiducial was found on it

    The top side carries 193 SMT component(s) but no fiducial was found on it — a placement machine has no optical reference to align to. Probe found no pad labelled .pad_usage=g_fiducial/l_fiducial (basis pad_usage); no single-pad, netless, undrilled component whose 0.5-3 mm round pad has a concentric solder-mask opening at least 1.5x its diameter with no other copper inside it (basis geometry); and no component whose refdes starts FID or whose part or package name contains FIDUCIAL (basis footprint-name). If your library names fiducials something Probe does not recognise, mark this benign — disposition_finding(rule='FiducialMissing', entity='top', status='benign', reason=…) — the name match only ever silences this check, it never asserts anything. If the side really has no fiducial, say so with status='confirmed': that answers the finding and keeps it gating release.

    At top

  7. observationOBS-268minorOpen

    Coax connector values disagree with their footprints on all nine input/output pairs

    On all nine coax input/output pairs, the connector value disagrees with its footprint: parts valued SMA sit on BNC or SMB footprints and parts valued BNC on SMB footprints, so the BOM names a connector that does not match its land pattern.

    RefdesValueOrder codeFootprintSource
    J201 (and J301-J1001)CONN_COAXIAL_SMAFarnell 2293854awallinKiCadFootprints:BNC_2PINnetlist; output stage sheet
    J202 (and J302-J1002)CONN_COAXIAL_BNCFarnell 1076295Connect:SMB_Straightnetlist; output stage sheet
    J101BNCBNC_2PIN, consistentnetlist
    J102SMAConnect:SMB_Straightnetlist

    The input pair repeats the pattern: J101 is consistent, J102 is not.

  8. observationOBS-269minorOpen

    C901-C904 are listed as fitted 10u in the BOM but the PSU sheet says they are not installed

    C901-C904 are listed as fitted 10u in the BOM, but the PSU sheet says they are not installed.

    SourceWhat it says
    Sheet 2 (FDA_PSU.kicad_sch) title-block comment"not installed. C901, C902, C903, C904"; the symbols carry value 10u
    PCB and designer BOMall four as 10u, 0805, no do-not-fit marking
  9. observationOBS-270minorOpen

    Output-stage resistor designators overlap on the top silkscreen

    Output-stage designators overlap on the top silkscreen, for example R203 over R204 beside U201, so these parts cannot be identified from the board.

    The designators of neighbouring 0805 parts are printed on top of each other:

    • R203 and R204, beside U201
    • C605 and R603, and R508 and R504, in the other stages (from the overview)

Main parts

Part numberMakerDescriptionWhere
LMH6702U101
LT1963AU1
LT3015U2
BNX025FL901, FL902
LMH6609U1001, U201, U301, U401, U501, U601, U701, U801

About this design

Design
FDA 8CH — OHWR0069 R1
Designed in
KiCad EDA
Board
2 copper layers, 170 × 70 mm, 416 components, 134 nets
Licence
CERN-OHL-1.2
Source
https://gitlab.com/ohwr/project/pda-8ch-fda-8ch at commit 911c25f444c6
Attribution
CERN Open Hardware Repository, project ohwr/project/pda-8ch-fda-8ch (commit 911c25f444c6630dac731f8eacf6c6b89fd4a4c7, 2025-04-09). Licence: CERN-OHL-1.2. Source: https://gitlab.com/ohwr/project/pda-8ch-fda-8ch. This is a snapshot of the copy published on the OHWR GitLab pages (R1), not CERN's released record. CERN's source of truth is EDMS (https://edms.cern.ch), and the current release may be newer.
Reviewed with
Probe by E# (E-Sharp AB)