Probe E# — E-Sharp AB
Probe is made by E# (E-Sharp AB) in Sweden. Want your own boards reviewed like this? Book a meeting

DIOT MONIMOD FANTRAY

OHWR0074 · revision R1 · a newer revision, R4, is listed

Revisions:R4R1

DIOT MONIMOD FANTRAY (OHWR0074 R1) is an open-hardware circuit board from the CERN Open Hardware Repository, designed in KiCad EDA: a 4-layer board of 190 × 40 mm with 149 components and 88 nets, published under CERN-OHL-W-2.0.

review 90% walked · 20 findings: 12 major · 8 minor (27 items)

Open in the interactive viewerRead the full review

DIOT MONIMOD FANTRAY (OHWR0074 R1) circuit board, top view: copper, silkscreen and components
Top view, rendered by Probe from the design's own fabrication data.

Design review

Probe recorded 20 findings: 12 major · 8 minor (27 items) on this design. Each is shown here with its reasoning; the full review links every one to the pins, nets and datasheet pages it rests on.

  1. observationOBS-500majorOpen

    IC6 3.3 V LDO: BOM orders TPS78633DCQ (pin 5 = NR) while the value says TPS7A4533DCQ (pin 5 = SENSE), and pin 5 is tied to the output

    The 3.3 V regulator IC6 is two different parts at once: its BOM row orders MPN TPS78633DCQ, but its value (and the schematic symbol's label) is TPS7A4533DCQ. Pin 5 is wired to P3V3, which is correct for the TPS7A4533 (SENSE) and wrong for the TPS78633, whose pin 5 is the NR noise-reduction node of the internal reference. Built with the ordered part, the reference filter node is driven from the output.

    ItemTPS7A4533DCQ (value)TPS78633DCQ (MPN ordered)Source
    Pin 5SENSE, tie to OUT for fixed versionsNR: 'Noise-reduction pin for fixed versions only. An external bypass capacitor, connected to this terminal, in conjunction with an internal resistor, creates a low-pass filter'TPS7A45 DS p3; TPS786 DS (SLVS389M) p3
    Pin 1SHDNENsame
    Max VIN20 V5.5 VTPS786 DS p6
    Min COUT10 uF ceramic1 uF ceramicTPS7A45 DS p3; TPS786 DS p1
    On this boardpin 5 = P3V3 (OUT), pin 1 = shdn_n (R14 10k to P5V / R41 16k to GND), IN = P5Vnetlist

    The schematic symbol (sheet 2) prints TPS786 pin names (EN, NR) with a TPS7A4533DCQ value, so the drawing itself carries both identities. The sibling board OHWR0073 DIOT MONIMOD orders TPS7A4533DCQ for the same circuit. With TPS7A4533 fitted the wiring is right but the output capacitance (C31 10 uF + C24/C30 1 uF + 3 x 100 nF, about 8 uF effective after DC-bias derating of the 0603 10 uF) is at or below its 10 uF minimum.

    Which part is meant needs settling in the BOM before the next build.

  2. observationOBS-554majorOpen

    BAT54C went end-of-life (Obsolete)

    Vendor (DigiKey) lifecycle for BAT54C (onsemi's listing) changed from "Active" to "Obsolete" since this board was reviewed. Placed as D10, D12, D16, D17, D18, D19, D2, D20, D21, D4, D6, D8. A sourcing/longevity risk; consider a replacement before production.

  3. observationOBS-598majorOpen

    BZX84C5V1 went end-of-life (Obsolete)

    Vendor (DigiKey) lifecycle for BZX84C5V1 (onsemi's listing) changed from "Active" to "Obsolete" since this board was reviewed. Placed as D1, D11, D3, D5, D7, D9. A sourcing/longevity risk; consider a replacement before production.

  4. observationOBS-600majorOpen

    22-04-1031 went end-of-life (Discontinued at DigiKey)

    Vendor (DigiKey) lifecycle for 22-04-1031 (Molex's listing) changed from "Active" to "Discontinued at DigiKey" since this board was reviewed. Placed as J1, J3, J4. A sourcing/longevity risk; consider a replacement before production.

  5. concernCON-003majorOpen

    [eol:22-04-1031:Discontinued at DigiKey] 22-04-1031 lifecycle changed from "Active" to "Discontinued at DigiKey" since this board was reviewed: OHWR0074 R1 DIOT MONIMOD FANTRAY. A sourcing and longevity risk. Should this be replaced before the next build?

  6. concernCON-001majorOpen

    [eol:BAT54C:Obsolete] BAT54C lifecycle changed from "Active" to "Obsolete" since this board was reviewed: OHWR0074 R1 DIOT MONIMOD FANTRAY. A sourcing and longevity risk. Should this be replaced before the next build?

  7. concernCON-002majorOpen

    [eol:BZX84C5V1:Obsolete] BZX84C5V1 lifecycle changed from "Active" to "Obsolete" since this board was reviewed: OHWR0074 R1 DIOT MONIMOD FANTRAY. A sourcing and longevity risk. Should this be replaced before the next build?

  8. FiducialMissingmajorOpen

    FiducialMissing: 2 boards×2

    2 checked by the review by a reviewer — 2 different reasons

    At bottom, top

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • bottomThe bottom side carries 26 SMT component(s) and no fiducial was found on it

      The bottom side carries 26 SMT component(s) but no fiducial was found on it — a placement machine has no optical reference to align to. Probe found no pad labelled .pad_usage=g_fiducial/l_fiducial (basis pad_usage); no single-pad, netless, undrilled component whose 0.5-3 mm round pad has a concentric solder-mask opening at least 1.5x its diameter with no other copper inside it (basis geometry); and no component whose refdes starts FID or whose part or package name contains FIDUCIAL (basis footprint-name). If your library names fiducials something Probe does not recognise, mark this benign — disposition_finding(rule='FiducialMissing', entity='bottom', status='benign', reason=…) — the name match only ever silences this check, it never asserts anything. If the side really has no fiducial, say so with status='confirmed': that answers the finding and keeps it gating release.

    • topThe top side carries 105 SMT component(s) and no fiducial was found on it

      The top side carries 105 SMT component(s) but no fiducial was found on it — a placement machine has no optical reference to align to. Probe found no pad labelled .pad_usage=g_fiducial/l_fiducial (basis pad_usage); no single-pad, netless, undrilled component whose 0.5-3 mm round pad has a concentric solder-mask opening at least 1.5x its diameter with no other copper inside it (basis geometry); and no component whose refdes starts FID or whose part or package name contains FIDUCIAL (basis footprint-name). If your library names fiducials something Probe does not recognise, mark this benign — disposition_finding(rule='FiducialMissing', entity='top', status='benign', reason=…) — the name match only ever silences this check, it never asserts anything. If the side really has no fiducial, say so with status='confirmed': that answers the finding and keeps it gating release.

  9. PartLifecyclemajorOpen

    PartLifecycle: 2 part numbers×2

    2 Obsolete · on 18 placements

    At D1, D10

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • D1BZX84C5V1 on 6 placements (D1, D11, D3, D5, D7, D9): the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for onsemi's BZX84C5V1

      BZX84C5V1 on 6 placements (D1, D11, D3, D5, D7, D9): the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for onsemi's BZX84C5V1 — a sourcing/longevity risk to confirm against the MANUFACTURER before acting. This board's BOM names FAIRCHILD SEMICONDUCTOR, and that is one line with onsemi: ON Semiconductor completed its acquisition of Fairchild Semiconductor on 2016-09-19 and renamed itself onsemi on 2021-08-05. A distributor delisting is not the same claim as the part being unavailable; check the vendor's own lifecycle/product-change notice for the status and any named successor. Re-read the source: GET /api/odb/parts/BZX84C5V1/providers (which provider said it, the maker and part number it matched, its own words, and when we asked). THE LAST BUY DATE HAS PASSED (2017-11-19, 3,283 day(s) ago), so this is a substitution rather than a buy. The distributor reports NONE left. No approved alternate is recorded for this position.

    • D10BAT54C on 12 placements (D10, D12, D16, D17, D18, D19, D2, D20, …): the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for onsemi's BAT54C

      BAT54C on 12 placements (D10, D12, D16, D17, D18, D19, D2, D20, …): the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for onsemi's BAT54C — a sourcing/longevity risk to confirm against the MANUFACTURER before acting. This board's BOM names FAIRCHILD SEMICONDUCTOR, and that is one line with onsemi: ON Semiconductor completed its acquisition of Fairchild Semiconductor on 2016-09-19 and renamed itself onsemi on 2021-08-05. A distributor delisting is not the same claim as the part being unavailable; check the vendor's own lifecycle/product-change notice for the status and any named successor. Re-read the source: GET /api/odb/parts/BAT54C/providers (which provider said it, the maker and part number it matched, its own words, and when we asked). THE LAST BUY DATE HAS PASSED (2018-09-30, 2,968 day(s) ago), so this is a substitution rather than a buy. The distributor reports 54,983 left. No approved alternate is recorded for this position.

  10. PartLifecyclemajorOpen

    PartLifecycle: 2 part numbers×2

    1 Not For New Designs, 1 Obsolete · on 2 placements

    At F1, IC10

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • F1MF-MSMF110/16-2 on F1: the distributor catalogue reports "Not For New Designs" for Bourns Inc.'s MF-MSMF110/16-2

      MF-MSMF110/16-2 on F1: the distributor catalogue reports "Not For New Designs" for Bourns Inc.'s MF-MSMF110/16-2 — a sourcing/longevity risk to confirm against the MANUFACTURER before acting. That is the maker this board's BOM names (BOURNS). A distributor delisting is not the same claim as the part being unavailable; check the vendor's own lifecycle/product-change notice for the status and any named successor. Re-read the source: GET /api/odb/parts/MF-MSMF110/16-2/providers (which provider said it, the maker and part number it matched, its own words, and when we asked). No approved alternate is recorded for this position.

    • IC10LM45CIM3/NOPB on IC10: the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for Texas Instruments's LM45CIM3/NOPB

      LM45CIM3/NOPB on IC10: the distributor catalogue reports "Obsolete" for Texas Instruments's LM45CIM3/NOPB — a sourcing/longevity risk to confirm against the MANUFACTURER before acting. That is the maker this board's BOM names (TEXAS INSTRUMENTS). A distributor delisting is not the same claim as the part being unavailable; check the vendor's own lifecycle/product-change notice for the status and any named successor. Re-read the source: GET /api/odb/parts/LM45CIM3/NOPB/providers (which provider said it, the maker and part number it matched, its own words, and when we asked). THE LAST BUY DATE HAS PASSED (2024-02-09, 1,010 day(s) ago), so this is a substitution rather than a buy. The distributor reports NONE left. No approved alternate is recorded for this position.

  11. ReferencePlaneDiscontinuitymajorOpen

    ReferencePlaneDiscontinuity: 2 boards×2

    Checked by the review, stands · Claude walker W1 (Cern session) — Checked: splits and reference changes read from the copper stand; they sit on slow ADC and control nets of a microcontroller board, and no datasheet or app note on file sets a limit. Not refutable with a citation; left for the owner.

    At split@IN2.CU:GND|P3V3, void:routed@B.CU|IN2.CU

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • split@IN2.CU:GND|P3V33 nets cross the split between the GND and P3V3 planes on IN2.CU at 8 places, with no plane on the track's other side (fastest: /Analog/I_adc3 at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      On IN2.CU the GND and P3V3 planes part, and 3 nets cross from one to the other at 8 place(s). The return current cannot follow a track across; it detours to wherever the two planes are joined (a stitching capacitor, or the source), and the loop it opens radiates and couples. One decision covers the boundary: whether it is stitched near these crossings, or the nets crossing it are slow enough not to care. Tracks that run ALONG this split, down the slot rather than across it, are a finding of their own: theirs is an impedance step, not a detour. At 0 of the 8 crossing(s) the track's other neighbour carries a plane, which the return can use there; 8 are on an outer layer, with no other neighbour. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • '/Analog/I_adc3' on B.CU at (165.8, -103.69), 0.37 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/Analog/I_adc3' on B.CU at (166.37, -103.13), 0.37 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/Analog/V_adc1' on B.CU at (171.96, -108.07), 0.36 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/Analog/V_adc1' on B.CU at (171.96, -105.8), 0.38 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/T_adc1' on B.CU at (156.62, -103.85), 0.41 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/T_adc1' on B.CU at (164.98, -103.69), 0.37 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/T_adc1' on B.CU at (166.43, -102.24), 0.54 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/T_adc1' on B.CU at (169.67, -99), 0.37 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/75/reference-planes?group=split%40IN2.CU%3AGND%7CP3V3 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 155.47..172.96, y -109.25..-97.87 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • void:routed@B.CU|IN2.CUTracks on B.CU and IN2.CU cross each other at 6 places, each layer the other's reference with its pour cleared round its own tracks, the longest 3.25 mm (fastest: /Analog/I_adc1 at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      B.CU and IN2.CU each carry a pour and routed tracks, and each is the other's nearest reference. Wherever a track on one crosses a track on the other, the pour under it is cleared round that other track, so for the width of the cut the return has no plane under it and detours round the cut. 6 place(s) on 7 net(s), 1 of them seen from both tracks (each counted once). One decision covers the layer pair: whether these layers may take a pour their own tracks cut as the reference, or the routing or the stackup should give the tracks a plane that is not cut where they cross. 2 of the 9 crossing(s) have a plane on the track's other side at most twice as far away as the broken one (to first order each plane beside a stripline carries a share of the return inversely proportional to its distance from the track). The rest leave most or all of the return to the break, so the finding is a warning.

      • one crossing of two tracks, seen from each: '/Analog/I_adc1' on B.CU at (104.97, -95.95), 1.99 mm over copper of /Fan_ctrl_h1, /Fan_ctrl_l1, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost / '/Analog/I_adc2' on B.CU at (106.43, -95.95), 1.99 mm over copper of /Fan_ctrl_l1, /Fan_ctrl_h1, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost / '/Fan_ctrl_h1' on IN2.CU at (105.38, -96.27), 3.25 mm over copper of /Analog/I_adc2, /Analog/I_adc1, not a plane; other side: GND on IN1.CU, 0.48 mm from the track against 0.48 mm to B.CU: 50% of the return on B.CU / '/Fan_ctrl_l1' on IN2.CU at (106.02, -95.62), 3.25 mm over copper of /Analog/I_adc1, /Analog/I_adc2, not a plane; other side: GND on IN1.CU, 0.48 mm from the track against 0.48 mm to B.CU: 50% of the return on B.CU
      • '/T_adc1' on B.CU at (155.83, -103.06), 1.43 mm over copper of +5VA, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/Analog/I_adc3' on B.CU at (153.22, -101.85), 1.43 mm over copper of +5VA, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/T_adc1' on B.CU at (154.62, -101.85), 1.43 mm over copper of +5VA, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • 'Net-(IC7-Pad3)' on B.CU at (175.06, -112.84), 1.01 mm over copper of +5VA, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/Analog/I_adc3' on B.CU at (138.56, -100.59), 1 mm over copper of +5VA, not a plane; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/75/reference-planes?group=void%3Arouted%40B.CU%7CIN2.CU serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 102.75..176.06, y -114.34..-94.24 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

  12. ReferencePlaneDiscontinuitymajorOpen

    ReferencePlaneDiscontinuity: 3 boards×3

    3 checked by the review by Claude walker X2 (cern-01 session) — 3 different reasons

    At refchange:GND|P3V3, split@IN2.CU:GND|P3V3_AUX, split@IN2.CU:P3V3|P3V3_AUX

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • refchange:GND|P3V33 nets change reference between GND and P3V3 at 3 vias, none with a reference that continues across (fastest: /Analog/I_adc3 at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      At 3 via(s), on 3 net(s), the signal leaves a layer referenced by one of GND and P3V3 for a layer referenced by the other, and no plane references both layers. Different nets: no via can carry the return across; only decoupling between the two planes near the via can. The capacitor carrying the return across was measured at each via, at the knee of the crossing net's edge against 50 ohm assumed: 3 with none. 3 of them at an ASSUMED edge (no edge on file for the net): state one (net_timing_state) and it is re-read. One decision covers the pair: whether GND and P3V3 are decoupled to each other near these vias. A via whose layers have more references than these two is a site of each pair it joins. None is partial: at every one, no reference continues across the via.

      • '/Analog/I_adc3' at (169.54, -101.54), F.CU -> B.CU: GND on IN1.CU to P3V3 on IN2.CU; pure, no reference continues across; stitching none, 41.5 mm of track past the via on B.CU: At the 5 GHz knee of a 100 ps edge (100 ps 10-90 %, assumed: no edge is on file for the net) no capacitor carries the return; only the planes do. GND and P3V3 are not a thin pair (at most 0.2 mm), so their own capacitance does not carry the return. To serve it, change layers across the same plane, or move the signal to a layer referenced to ground. Measured for reference: C25 (100 nF 0603) 2.6 mm away: 0.58 nH in the 0.480 mm cavity + 0.51 nH ESL + 0.68 nH mounting (pad 0.10 nH + no via of the first net within 1 mm of its pad: the study's 0.6 nH per mm of 0.96 mm depth, ASSUMED): 55.4 ohm at the knee, 111 % of 50 ohm (assumed track impedance). None.
      • '/pgm_rst_n' at (179.32, -110.36), F.CU -> B.CU: GND on IN1.CU to P3V3 on IN2.CU; pure, no reference continues across; stitching none, 6.6 mm of track past the via on B.CU: At the 5 GHz knee of a 100 ps edge (20 ns 10-90 %, assumed: no edge is on file for the net) no capacitor carries the return; only the planes do. GND and P3V3 are not a thin pair (at most 0.2 mm), so their own capacitance does not carry the return. To serve it, change layers across the same plane, or move the signal to a layer referenced to ground. None.
      • '/swclk' at (180.34, -110.36), F.CU -> B.CU: GND on IN1.CU to P3V3 on IN2.CU; pure, no reference continues across; stitching none, 5.7 mm of track past the via on B.CU: At the 5 GHz knee of a 100 ps edge (1 ns 10-90 %, assumed: no edge is on file for the net) no capacitor carries the return; only the planes do. GND and P3V3 are not a thin pair (at most 0.2 mm), so their own capacitance does not carry the return. To serve it, change layers across the same plane, or move the signal to a layer referenced to ground. None.

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/75/reference-planes?group=refchange%3AGND%7CP3V3 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 167.54..182.34, y -112.36..-99.54 mm (board frame, Y up).

      The reference on each layer is the first plane the track meets leaving the via, anti-pads and the net's own copper skipped. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • split@IN2.CU:GND|P3V3_AUX2 nets cross the split between the GND and P3V3_AUX planes on IN2.CU at 2 places, with no plane on the track's other side (fastest: /swclk at 1 ns 10-90 %, suggested by its name)

      On IN2.CU the GND and P3V3_AUX planes part, and 2 nets cross from one to the other at 2 place(s). The return current cannot follow a track across; it detours to wherever the two planes are joined (a stitching capacitor, or the source), and the loop it opens radiates and couples. One decision covers the boundary: whether it is stitched near these crossings, or the nets crossing it are slow enough not to care. Tracks that run ALONG this split, down the slot rather than across it, are a finding of their own: theirs is an impedance step, not a detour. At 0 of the 2 crossing(s) the track's other neighbour carries a plane, which the return can use there; 2 are on an outer layer, with no other neighbour. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • '/pgm_rst_n' on B.CU at (179.32, -105.22), 0.36 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/swclk' on B.CU at (180.34, -106.04), 0.26 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/75/reference-planes?group=split%40IN2.CU%3AGND%7CP3V3_AUX serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 178.32..181.34, y -107.17..-104.04 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • split@IN2.CU:P3V3|P3V3_AUX2 nets cross the split between the P3V3 and P3V3_AUX planes on IN2.CU at 2 places, with no plane on the track's other side (fastest: /swclk at 1 ns 10-90 %, suggested by its name)

      On IN2.CU the P3V3 and P3V3_AUX planes part, and 2 nets cross from one to the other at 2 place(s). The return current cannot follow a track across; it detours to wherever the two planes are joined (a stitching capacitor, or the source), and the loop it opens radiates and couples. One decision covers the boundary: whether it is stitched near these crossings, or the nets crossing it are slow enough not to care. Tracks that run ALONG this split, down the slot rather than across it, are a finding of their own: theirs is an impedance step, not a detour. At 0 of the 2 crossing(s) the track's other neighbour carries a plane, which the return can use there; 2 are on an outer layer, with no other neighbour. No crossing has a plane on the track's other side, so the whole return meets the break.

      • '/pgm_rst_n' on B.CU at (179.32, -107.82), 0.63 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost
      • '/swclk' on B.CU at (180.34, -107.83), 0.63 mm; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/75/reference-planes?group=split%40IN2.CU%3AP3V3%7CP3V3_AUX serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 178.32..181.34, y -109.14..-106.51 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

  13. observationOBS-501minorOpen

    ADC reference IC5 (TL431) runs at 0.40 mA, below its 1 mA minimum, with 100 nF on its cathode inside the TL431 oscillation band

    Vref25, the MCU's ADC reference (IC4 PA03/VREFA), comes from IC5 TL431B biased by R10 = 2 k from P3V3_AUX: (3.3 - 2.495) / 2 k = 0.40 mA, below the 1 mA minimum operating cathode current. C19 = 100 nF directly on the cathode is inside the region Nexperia's Fig. 17 marks as oscillation at low cathode current.

    QuantityValueSource
    Bias resistorR10 2 k, P3V3_AUX to Vref25netlist
    Cathode current available0.40 mAcomputed
    Recommended cathode current1 mA minNexperia TL431 Rev. 8, Table 8, p6
    I_K(min) TL431B0.4 typ, 0.6 max mATable 10, p8
    Load capacitanceC19 100 nFnetlist / BOM
    Oscillation band at low IKabout 5 nF to 350 nFFig. 17, p12 (typical)

    The only other loads are IC4's VREFA input and TP4, so the reference may sit at its nominal voltage, but it is out of its rated operating range and its accuracy is not specified there. The same circuit on OHWR0073 DIOT MONIMOD is OBS-494/OBS-495. A bias of about 1-2 mA (R10 about 470 R) and a capacitor outside the band would fix it.

  14. observationOBS-502minorOpen

    No fiducials on either side, with 114 SMT parts on top (including a 0.5 mm-pitch QFP) and 26 on the bottom

    OHWR0074 R1 DIOT MONIMOD FANTRAY carries no fiducial on either side: no FTG/FID component, no fiducial pad, while the top holds 114 SMT placements including IC4, the 48-pin 0.5 mm-pitch SAMD21 QFP, and the bottom 26. Its sibling OHWR0073 DIOT MONIMOD has three top-side fiducials (FTG1-FTG3). A panel may carry global fiducials, but nothing in the board data provides them.

    SideSMT placementsFiducialsSource
    Top1140ODB++ placement, layer view
    Bottom260ODB++ placement
  15. observationOBS-610minorOpen

    Buffer IC7 on always-on +5VA drives the SAMD21's ADC pins while shdn_n holds its P3V3 off (fan tray R1)

    While the crate holds shdn_n low, IC6 turns P3V3 off, but OPA2192 IC7 on always-on +5VA keeps driving /Analog/V_adc1 and /Analog/V_adc2 into the unpowered SAMD21 (IC4 pins 8 and 7).

    RailSourceSwitched?
    P5VJ5.11always on
    +5VAP5V through L5always on
    P3V3IC6 TPS78633 from P5VEN = shdn_n (J5.9)

    CERN is asked to confirm IC7's outputs stay inside the SAMD21's limits with it unpowered, or to switch +5VA with P3V3. The same arrangement on the later revision OHWR0074 R4 is OBS-586.

  16. observationOBS-611minorOpen

    Silkscreen: TP9 and C22 designators overlap beside R11, and C30/TP5/C31 run together beside L4

    Two designator collisions on the top silkscreen leave parts ambiguous at assembly and rework.

    On Probe's top assembly drawing (rendered at 2600 px across the 190 mm outline, about 13.7 px/mm): the TP9 and C22 designators are printed into each other next to R11 near IC3, and C30, TP5 and C31 are stacked so closely beside L4 (next to J2) that they read as one block.

  17. observationOBS-644minorOpen

    1 clock net (SWD clock /swclk) crosses plane gaps with no return path at 3 places

    The SWD clock /swclk, driven into the fan tray from the system board through the Fan Tray cable (J5.13) or from the bench header J2.4, changes reference from GND (IN1.CU) to P3V3 (IN2.CU) at one via with no stitching capacitor near it, then runs on B.CU across two splits in the IN2.CU plane with no plane on its other side: its return current has no continuous path at these three sites.

    Read from the copper as drawn (Probe's reference-plane screen on this take). No edge rate is on file for this net (its driver is off this board), so no noise figure is claimed; the geometry is exact.

    Sites

    NetSitePosition (mm)LayerGap / changeOther side
    /swclkvia, reference change(180.34, -110.36)F.CU to B.CUGND on IN1.CU to P3V3 on IN2.CU, no stitching capacitor; 5.7 mm of track follows on B.CUnone continues across
    /swclksplit crossing(180.34, -107.83)B.CU over IN2.CU0.63 mm split between P3V3 and P3V3_AUXnone: outermost layer
    /swclksplit crossing(180.34, -106.04)B.CU over IN2.CU0.26 mm split between GND and P3V3_AUXnone: outermost layer

    Why it is raised

    It is the only clock on this board crossing a gap without a return path; the other crossings (fan PWM and tacho, analog sense, reset) are slow or static and were checked as layout practice. A ground via beside the signal via and routing the B.CU stretch over a single plane removes all three.

  18. observationOBS-648minorOpen

    Fan-tray input fuse F1 is two different parts: drawn and valued MF-MSMF150/12 (3 A trip, 12 V max), ordered as MF-MSMF110/16 (1.1 A hold, 16 V max)

    The PTC fuse F1 on the crate's 12 V input (J5 to P12V) is a different part depending on where you read it. The schematic labels it "3A-12V" and the BOM row's value is FUSR_BOURNS_MF-MSMF150/12-2, but the same row orders MF-MSMF110/16-2. The two differ in hold current and in maximum voltage, and the 12 V variant would sit at its own voltage limit on this 12 V rail. The R4 fan tray carries the same row (OBS-647).

    The two candidates

    PartV maxI holdI tripSource
    MF-MSMF150/12 (schematic "3A-12V", BOM value)12 V1.50 A3.00 ABourns MF-MSMF datasheet p2
    MF-MSMF110/16 (BOM MPN)16 V1.10 A2.20 ABourns MF-MSMF datasheet p1

    Why it matters

    Whichever is fitted sets the fan current the tray carries before tripping (1.1 A versus 1.5 A hold), and the 150/12's 12 V maximum leaves no margin over a 12 V supply. Label, value and MPN should name one part.

  19. ConnectorDomainMixedminorOpen

    J5 takes 2 different supplies off the board on one connector: Net-(F1-Pad2) (12.0 V), P5V (5.0 V)

    J5 carries 2 different supplies out of the board on one connector: Net-(F1-Pad2) (12.0 V) on 2/4/6/8, P5V (5.0 V) on 11. Declare the intent. Two rails on one connector is ordinary in a docking or power-distribution interface and a hazard in a signal one, and the difference is not visible from the netlist — but note that adjacent contacts at different voltages are exactly what a mirrored, reversed or off-by-one cable shorts together, so the cost of getting the mating wrong is a rail collision rather than a dead signal. If this is a standard connector, declare its family (connector_family_declare) and file the standard's contact map: supplies on the contacts it assigns to power are then not reported.

    At J5

  20. ReferencePlaneDiscontinuityminorOpen

    ReferencePlaneDiscontinuity: 2 boards×2

    Checked by the review, stands · Claude walker W1 (Cern session) — Checked: splits and reference changes read from the copper stand; they sit on slow ADC and control nets of a microcontroller board, and no datasheet or app note on file sets a limit. Not refutable with a citation; left for the owner.

    At along@IN2.CU:GND|P3V3, along@IN2.CU:GND|P3V3_AUX

    Each finding, with its own headline
    • along@IN2.CU:GND|P3V3'/Analog/I_adc3' runs ALONG the split between the GND and P3V3 planes on IN2.CU at 1 place, the longest 7.73 mm; the impedance rises from 77 ohm to 82 ohm there at worst, 3.2 % of each edge reflected (fastest: /Analog/I_adc3 at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      On IN2.CU the GND and P3V3 planes part, and '/Analog/I_adc3' runs down the slot between them at 1 place(s), rather than across it. This is not a crossing: the return still follows the track, in the plane on its other side and in the slot's edges, so it does not detour. What changes is the track's own impedance. With the plane gone from under it on this side for that length, its field reaches further, to the slot's edges and to the next plane beyond, so its capacitance falls and its impedance rises; every edge travelling down it is partly reflected where it enters the stretch and again where it leaves, by (Z2 - Z1)/(Z2 + Z1). The longer the stretch against the edge's rise, the more of the edge sees the full step. A crossing is generally the worse fault; a mismatch is not free. Over solid plane each track is 77 ohm; along the slot 82 ohm, reflecting up to 3.2 % of each edge (a method-of-moments field solve of the cross-section, one dielectric; were the slot's edges to carry none of the return, up to 97 ohm). At every place the rise is within 10 %, the tolerance controlled impedance is commonly built to (the stackup states none), so the finding is the lower tier (info). One decision covers the split line's slot: whether these tracks may run down it, or should be moved over solid plane.

      • '/Analog/I_adc3' on B.CU at (160.74, -105.22), 9.93 mm, running ALONG the split for 7.73 mm, not across it, 77 ohm over solid plane, 82 ohm along it: 3.2 % of each edge reflected; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/75/reference-planes?group=along%40IN2.CU%3AGND%7CP3V3 serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 154.32..165.59, y -106.22..-102.95 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

    • along@IN2.CU:GND|P3V3_AUX'/Analog/V_adc2' runs ALONG the split between the GND and P3V3_AUX planes on IN2.CU at 1 place, the longest 1.24 mm; the impedance rises from 77 ohm to 78 ohm there at worst, 0.5 % of each edge reflected (fastest: /Analog/V_adc2 at 100 ps 10-90 %, ASSUMED)

      On IN2.CU the GND and P3V3_AUX planes part, and '/Analog/V_adc2' runs down the slot between them at 1 place(s), rather than across it. This is not a crossing: the return still follows the track, in the plane on its other side and in the slot's edges, so it does not detour. What changes is the track's own impedance. With the plane gone from under it on this side for that length, its field reaches further, to the slot's edges and to the next plane beyond, so its capacitance falls and its impedance rises; every edge travelling down it is partly reflected where it enters the stretch and again where it leaves, by (Z2 - Z1)/(Z2 + Z1). The longer the stretch against the edge's rise, the more of the edge sees the full step. A crossing is generally the worse fault; a mismatch is not free. Over solid plane each track is 77 ohm; along the slot 78 ohm, reflecting up to 0.5 % of each edge (a method-of-moments field solve of the cross-section, one dielectric; were the slot's edges to carry none of the return, up to 97 ohm). At every place the rise is within 10 %, the tolerance controlled impedance is commonly built to (the stackup states none), so the finding is the lower tier (info). One decision covers the split line's slot: whether these tracks may run down it, or should be moved over solid plane.

      • '/Analog/V_adc2' on B.CU at (172.41, -93.67), 1.97 mm, running ALONG the split for 1.24 mm, not across it, 77 ohm over solid plane, 78 ohm along it: 0.5 % of each edge reflected; other side: none: the signal layer is outermost

      Every site is a row of this finding's evidence, keyed by net, layers and position. GET /api/odb/boards/75/reference-planes?group=along%40IN2.CU%3AGND%7CP3V3_AUX serves each with its own layer_image region; all of them lie in x 171.41..173.74, y -95.42..-91.58 mm (board frame, Y up).

      Read from the copper as drawn on the reference layer, along each track's centreline at exact breakpoints. The reference is the copper beside the track, never the layer's type or name. Whether it matters depends on each signal's edge rate, which nothing on file states for these nets: a slow static line crosses a split harmlessly, a fast edge does not.

Main parts

Part numberMakerDescriptionWhere
ABM3B-8.000MHZ-B2-TABRACONQ1
ATSAMD21G18A-AFMICROCHIPIC4
FTS-105-02-F-DVSAMTECJ2
HTSW-101-23-L-DSAMTECJ6
L717DFA15S1ATNAMPHENOLJ5
LM45CIM3/NOPBTEXAS INSTRUMENTSIC10
MF-MSMF110/16-2BOURNSF1
TL431BQDBZNXP SEMICONDUCTORSIC5
TPS78633DCQTEXAS INSTRUMENTSIC6
22-04-1031MOLEXJ1, J3, J4
BC817-25NXP SEMICONDUCTORST7, T8, T9
ES1DFAIRCHILD SEMICONDUCTORD13, D14, D15
L6498DST MICROELECTRONICSIC1, IC2, IC3
OPA2192IDGKTEXAS INSTRUMENTSIC7, IC8, IC9
PLATED_HOLE2.7_PAD5.0B1, B2, B3, B4
BZX84C5V1FAIRCHILD SEMICONDUCTORD1, D11, D3, D5, D7, D9
IPD5N25S3-430INFINEONT1, T2, T3, T4, T5, T6
SMD_PAD_1.27X1.27MMTP1, TP2, TP3, TP4, TP5, TP6 and 3 more
BAT54CFAIRCHILD SEMICONDUCTORD10, D12, D16, D17, D18, D19 and 6 more
BLM18PG121SN1DMURATAL4, L5
CC0603_10UF_16V_20%_X5RGENERICC29, C31
CC0603_22PF_50V_5%_NP0GENERICC20, C21
R0603_16K_1%_0.1W_100PPMGENERICR20, R41
CC0603_100NF_50V_10%_X5RGENERICC25, C26, C27
CC0603_1uF_16V_10%_X7RGENERICC23, C24, C30
CTE6032-28_22UF_25V_10%_LESR0250GENERICC15, C3, C9
DO3316P-473MLDCOILCRAFTL10, L6, L8
R0805_0R05_1%_0.25W_300PPMGENERICR13, R40, R42
R0603_2K_1%_0.1W_100PPMGENERICR10, R16, R19, R24, R28
CC0603_1NF_50V_10%_X7RGENERICC40, C41, C42, C43, C44, C45
GMJ316BB7106KLHTTAIYO YUDENC1, C10, C13, C16, C4, C7
R0603_200R_1%_0.1W_100PPMGENERICR17, R18, R21, R23, R26, R27
R0603_10K_1%_0.1W_100PPMGENERICR12, R14, R15, R22, R25, R29, R39
R0603_1K_1%_0.1W_100PPMGENERICR11, R30, R33, R34, R37, R38, R8
R0603_10R_1%_0.1W_200PPMGENERICR1, R2, R3, R31, R32, R35 and 6 more
CC0603_100NF_50V_10%_X7RGENERICC11, C12, C14, C17, C18, C19 and 10 more

About this design

Design
DIOT MONIMOD FANTRAY — OHWR0074 R1
Designed in
KiCad EDA
Board
4 copper layers, 190 × 40 mm, 149 components, 88 nets
Licence
CERN-OHL-W-2.0
Source
https://gitlab.com/ohwr/project/diot-monimod at commit 4e7c8230d0e1
Attribution
CERN Open Hardware Repository, project ohwr/project/diot-monimod (commit 4e7c8230d0e14c7e6820d53feef058688390b835, 2025-04-10). Licence: CERN-OHL-W-2.0. Source: https://gitlab.com/ohwr/project/diot-monimod. This is a snapshot of the copy published on the OHWR GitLab pages (R1), not CERN's released record. CERN's source of truth is EDMS (https://edms.cern.ch), and the current release may be newer.
Reviewed with
Probe by E# (E-Sharp AB)